So, an acquaintance just asked me for tips for her upcoming trip to New York, which is hilarious, since I am the worst traveler and would make an even worse tour guide. Plus, she said they
do not intend to see a Broadway show. That was when I blacked out. When I came to, I realized I have actually made four pilgrimages in six years to the Great White Way! Here's my two cents:
TRANSPORTATION
We took Uber and/or a cab from JFK airport to Manhattan and back again. Either method is about $60 one way, and other car services, Lyft, etc. are comparable. You can also try Ubershare, which is cheaper, where you share a ride with someone else. A trip from the airport to Times Square will take anywhere from 30 to 90 minutes depending on time of day. There are shuttle buses that go to and from all three airports, and tickets are about half that price, but you need to allow a LOT more time and prepare to make a lot of stops. We have also taken the Subway from Newark to Manhattan. It is OK, just crowded and slow, and hard to maneuver with luggage. Getting from place to place, we mostly walk or cab. The subway runs everywhere, and is of course much cheaper, but it is not like the Metro in D.C. or even BART in San Francisco. It is dirty, smelly and really confusing. Find someone to give you a tutorial, if you dare!
SIGHTSEEING
The 9/11 memorial and museum is a must-see. We meant to go again last week, but then Hamilton intervened. I understand you can now go up in the tower. Doing a walking tour around that entire area of the financial district is really cool. When you are down that way, you are not far from the landing to go to Ellis Island and the Statue of Liberty. (You could do these things in one day.) I don't know how the ferry works seasonally, but that is also a very cool place to visit. The ferry ride across the channel can be quite rocky-- I am a Dramamine fan. All these places have timed tickets/tours, so you want to plan and purchase ahead of time, or you could end up standing around for a long time.
There are so many museums-- Museum of Math, Museum of Sex, etc.-- my favorite is the Metropolitan Museum of Art. I could spend days there. What an opportunity to see some of the most famous works of art in all of world history! There's no entrance fee, just a donation, and they will search your bags, no water bottles. We have just wandered on our own, but you want to use a map to find the Monet gallery, the Van Goghs, and all those other famous works. The Met borders Central Park, so it's a good time to wander over there, too, just to say you've been there! I would not walk through the park at night. There is a small, free museum about the history of Broadway, right on Time Square... good place to take a break, with public bathrooms, if needed.
The Empire State Building, Top of the Rock, and such sights are also so cool... kind of have to hit the ones you can, but this is an hour or two at each place, if you time it right. The top of the Empire State Building at night is amazing! I'd skip the Radio City Music Hall tour-- it's kind of boring-- but, if the holiday show is already playing when you go, I have heard it is fantastic! Places like Madison Square Garden, Grand Central Station, etc. are just big, filthy and crowded.
We have also done one of those double-decker bus tours (Grey Line, I think.) These are great if you want to hit a bunch of sights just to say you saw them. You can buy more than one day at a time, and it becomes a pretty cost-effective way to travel. This is a good thing to do on a Monday because most museums are closed and most theaters are dark on Mondays.
It's fun just to walk around different areas and see how they feel. There's fancy housing on the Upper East Side and Upper West Side, adjacent to Central Park. The flower district is beautiful to walk through early in the morning. The flatiron district is super cool for trendy shops and great eating-- Gramercy Tavern, Craft, ABC Kitchen. There are also food trucks and an awesome Italian market called Eataly. It is a chain, so maybe not so special if you know it... but I could spend all day there. There are stations for appetizers, pizza, sandwiches, seafood, drinks, along with all kinds of speciality food shopping. I am (obviously) not a fashion shopper, but when you go to St. Patrick's Cathedral you will be very much in the area of Fifth Avenue and all the high-end stuff.
SAFETY
I have honestly never felt unsafe in the city. We stick around Times Square, the flower district, the flat iron district, and walk most everywhere. I wouldn't walk alone at night. Keep your bag close and in front of you. I love hoodies with zippered pockets. Everything moves quickly. Just use common sense.
MORE FOOD
Todd and I are really not into big meals out, unless it's a special occasion. Tavern on the Green is the standard, New York place to go. We hit super-casual, meals on the run, and are mostly around Times Square: Bareburger, Shake Shack (which is now at MOA, so not uniquely New York), Junior's for cheesecake and/or breakfast, Sardi's, Bella Vita Pizzeria on West 43rd St. If the weather is nice, there is a cool, rooftop bar near the Empire State Building called The Monarch.
THEATER
If you do decide to take in a show, you can just wait until the day of to purchase tickets. The best information, and usually the best prices, come from going to each theater's box office. You can also visit the red tkts booth on Times Square, and there's a tkts app that lists the shows with discount tickets each day. It's fun to wait in line and talk with other theatergoers about their recommendations. I just found out about another app called Today Tix where you can find out about same-day ticket availability and discounts, and purchase directly through the app. It is very easy to use.