It seemed the geneticist spent much of yesterday's appointment reassuring us about our son. I'm guessing we are the kind of parents who seek reassurance, and this is the kind of situation where the doctor could offer it. She told us while some of Benjamin's physical characteristics are not "typical," that does not mean they are "abnormal" or "wrong." This plays to a bigger topic that spins around my brain and rears itself in my home on a daily basis.
As parents, we are constantly comparing our children-- to our other children, to other people's children. We say we shouldn't. We say it doesn't matter. We may even say we don't. But we do. In nearly all circumstances, we want our children to be normal, but we do NOT want them to be average. We want them to be above average. What is it about Garrison Keillor's Lake Wobegon? "All the women are strong, all the men are good looking, and all the children are above average." (I truly cannot believe I just quoted Garrison Keillor. The man spoke at my SIL's college graduation and I nearly fell asleep.)
The one exception to this, I believe, is physical size... which is where Ben comes into play. From the day a child is born, height and weight (and head circumference, but don't get me started on that) are plotted on a growth chart with a corresponding percentile placement. If a child measures at the 50th percentile for all areas, the numbers receive a shrug of acceptance. If a child falls into a higher percentile for height, all the better, and parents credit their great genes. However, if a child falls into a lower percentile for height, parents sometimes blame the genes, wonder if there's a problem, anticipate ways for the child to "catch up" in height-- especially if that child is a boy. Then, there's weight. If a child measures significantly above or below average for weight, this, too, is the parents' fault. Skinny baby? Mom must not have had good nutrition while gestating. Skinny kid? Parents must not feed that child enough. Fat baby? Mom must have eaten too much while gestating. Fat kid? Parents must feed that child too much fast food, too much candy, too much juice, too much chocolate milk, too many bedtime snacks.
On the other hand, when it comes to academics, artistic ability, athleticism, well, then, all parents expect their children to be exceptional. In all these areas, average is somehow a disappointment. And isn't that sad. What's wrong with average? Can I only ask this question because everything I've seen in my own children suggests to me that they are of above-average intelligence?
My father, who spent the last years of his career in education analyzing student achievement, has become a crusader against inflated grades. He talks about instances where teachers do not even award grades lower than a "B" because it creates so much turmoil among students and their parents. But, he reminds everyone, a "C" is average. All those kids in the middle should be C students. And that should be OK. But, somehow, it isn't.
And, let's say some children, for example, the children of Krinkeland, are above average. What then? Amanda recently took her first set of standardized tests, where she exhibited above-average ability in math and way-above-average ability in reading. Elisabeth entered kindergarten already able to read, while some children are still working on learning the letters of the alphabet. You'll remember an early childhood assessment of Benjamin around his third birthday showed him to have the cognitive awareness of a five-year-old. Wow! All this, wow! I have bragging rights, right? But, really, what am I supposed to do with it? If my children were behind the curve, I would certainly feel compelled to get them some help so they could "catch up." If they are ahead of the curve, am I failing them if I don't push them to lead the pack and achieve, achieve, achieve?
I have a friend who is fond of the term "twice exceptional" or "2e." It refers to a child who is obviously gifted but also shows a sufficient area of weakness. Most often, this presents itself in one who tests at a gifted level but performs poorly in school due to some kind of learning disability. But sometimes it is also used to contrast high intelligence with physical incapability, for example, a 10-year-old who is mastering trigonometry but cannot hop on one foot. I guess if I was into labeling, I could put our son in this category.
Things get even more interesting when both parents don't see eye-to-eye about learning approaches for their children. In our household, one parent is more aggressive about "pushing" each kid to her or his fullest academic potential. The other is more concerned with moral attitudes, social behavior, the ability to make a friend, the responsibility to listen to adults and respect peers. I'm not saying one of us is right and the other is wrong. In all of this, I have no answers. I just observe and share. If I've said it once, I've said it a thousand times: Parenthood has taught me one thing, and that is that I know nothing.
Why be average? Why not? I mean, I'm a certifiable genius, and look where it's gotten me.
1 comment:
For a parent who knows nothing, you have certainly done a great job with the four of yours...keep up the good work...how much of this will really matter in the future? Ben will gain weight, Ben will grow, Ben will always be funny, anyway I hope he will. Sometimes, we all need to step back and live in the moment and watch just what is going on right now and not be so concerned about the future...God will handle that!
Post a Comment